Sutherlands Reviews

Sutherlands has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 72 reviews. Customer feedback on Sutherlands is mixed: Sutherlands reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide product selection, competitive pricing, helpful customer service, easy online ordering, which strongly appeal to home improvement enthusiasts, DIYers, contractors. However, Sutherlands is often criticized for its shipping delays, limited in-store availability, occasional product quality issues, website navigation challenges.

4.4/5.0

72 reviews

5 Stars

16

4 Stars

2

3 Stars

6

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Sutherlands Reviews (72)
henrycox5186
May 31, 2026
"Curbside pickup was okay, but check-in felt ignored"
I used sutherlands.com for curbside pickup and it was kind of a mixed experience. Placing the order online was easy, but after I checked in, I ended up waiting longer than I expected. It felt like nobody had read the message or noticed I was there until much later. The staff member who finally came out was nice, and my items were correct, so it wasn’t a huge problem. It just seemed a little unorganized. I’d probably use it again if I wasn’t in a hurry.
BenjaminKnauss
May 29, 2026
"They’ve always been reliable"
I’ve always trusted them, every experience I’ve had just kind of confirms what I already thought. They’ve never given me a reason to doubt them, so I’m happy to keep sticking with them.
thomasbenfield1818
May 28, 2026
"Really smooth rental experience"
I rented a floor sander from Sutherlands and had a great experience. The guy at the counter explained everything quickly, helped me get it loaded into my truck, and made the whole process super easy. The price seemed fair, the machine worked exactly like it was supposed to, and returning it was just as simple. I’d definitely rent from them again!
wesley.Canterbury
May 26, 2026
"Super easy to get to"
Sutherlands is really easy for me to get to since it’s right off the main road. Parking took about no effort at all, and I was in and out quick, which I definitely appreciated
carl_Tribble79
May 24, 2026
"Really nice install, even if I got the timing mixed up"
I had my install done through Sutherlands and overall I’m really happy with it. I’ll admit I was a little confused on the timeline at first, or maybe I just got the dates mixed up, but once the guys showed up they were right on time and got straight to work. They kept things clean, everything looks straight and solid, and they even fixed a small issue without turning it into a big deal. Really nice workmanship and I’m glad with how it all turned out.
hello_samuel443
May 16, 2026
"Payment was fine, but the financing info was ridiculous"
I ordered a few home items from sutherlands.com, and the regular checkout process was straightforward. I used a normal card payment option, and that part went through without any real issues.

I did look into the financing option too, but the way the details were laid out was kind of ridiculous. The info felt scattered, and I had to click further in before it started making much sense. I really wish they showed the terms more clearly up front.

Overall, it wasn’t a bad experience, just a little clunkier than I expected. I’d probably shop there again if the price was right, but I’d be more cautious with the financing stuff next time.
Anna-thomas
April 30, 2026
"Sutherlands.com is decent when I want to check..."
Sutherlands.com is decent when I want to check what they have before driving over, but the store hours can be kind of frustrating. A few times I’ve assumed I had enough time after work, only to realize they were closing earlier than I expected.

Weekends are usually convenient enough, but weekday evenings are hit or miss. I also wish the hours and store policies were clearer online, because it feels like there are little loopholes where something depends on the location or whoever you talk to. It’d be a lot better if they stayed open a bit later and made the details more straightforward.
Loren.savage
April 10, 2026
"Pretty smooth order overall"
I ordered a few things from Sutherlands and the shipping was mostly on time. One of the boxes showed up a little dented, maybe it just got knocked around during delivery, but everything inside was there and in good shape. Overall, it was a decent experience and I’d probably order from them again.
Amanda_carter78
April 08, 2026
"Return was way less stressful than I thought"
I had to send back an item because I ordered the wrong size, it was much easier than I expected. I was kind of bracing myself because my sister recently had a whole ordeal with a return from another store, but this went really smoothly. The refund showed up after a few days, there wasn’t any weird back-and-forth, and customer service was friendly enough. Painless overall...
marion.Levy
April 05, 2026
"Easy pickup, no hassle!"
Ordered some paint online and the whole checkout process was super easy :) My order was ready right when they said it would be, and everything went smoothly. No issues at all!
william2000
March 19, 2026
"I ordered a few things on sutherlands.com for..."
I ordered a few things on sutherlands.com for in-store pickup, and somehow the whole thing actually went smoothly. I got the “your order is ready” email sooner than I expected, which was a nice surprise because apparently miracles do happen.

When I got to the store, the pickup counter was easy to find, and the guy helping me was friendly. He checked my name, brought everything out, and I was out of there in about 5 minutes. i was prepared for at least a little hassle, but nope. Would definitely use it again.
jennie_Knauss95
March 08, 2026
"I pulled in expecting the usual loading-area..."
I pulled in expecting the usual loading-area saga, but it was almost too easy. Got in, got loaded up, and was back out with zero hassle. Felt like I dodged an entire episode of truck-stop drama.
SanfordAyala
March 02, 2026
"Easy account stuff, no issues"
I needed to update my email and look up an old order on my Sutherlands account, and I was in a tired mood at the time, so I was hoping it wouldn’t be a hassle. Luckily, everything was easy to find, and the login didn’t give me any trouble.
I also had to reset my password once, and that went smoothly too. Nothing fancy or overcomplicated, it just worked the way it was supposed to, which I really appreciated.
COMBS
February 25, 2026
"Found what I needed quickly"
The site was easy to get around, and I found the tools and outdoor stuff without much digging. The menus actually made sense, and checkout was straightforward. Overall, just a simple, hassle-free browsing experience.
COMBS
February 21, 2026
"Found what I needed quickly"
I was surprised they had as much in stock as they did. I found the lumber I needed and the small hardware pieces without wandering around forever. Checkout was easy too, and I got my receipt emailed to me right away, which was handy...
KeriTunney_40
February 17, 2026
"Honestly better than I expected"
I ordered a few things from Sutherlands and, to be honest, I was kind of expecting the usual online-order gamble where the photos look nicer than what actually shows up. But everything felt solid and well made, not cheap or flimsy, and it matched the pictures closely. It did make me wonder if they keep the good-looking stuff front and center to get people to come back, but in this case it worked on me. I’d probably order from them again.
kathy1994
February 16, 2026
"So... checkout was super quick"
So... I paid and had everything done in about a minute. No hassle, no messing around.
lori1980
January 19, 2026
"Coupon worked, rebate showed up"
I used the coupon without any issues, and the rebate came through just fine. i was half expecting some kind of hassle, because isn’t that usually how these things go?, but it was straightforward.
william_Rowan04
January 02, 2026
"Fair Prices and a Solid Value Overall"
I felt like the prices were fair overall, for what I got, it seemed like a good value. Nothing felt overpriced or unreasonable, which I always appreciate, and it was nice to feel like I was getting my money’s worth without having to overthink it too much.
MichaelSherman
December 25, 2025
"Decent store, but could use a little cleaning"
Not gonna lie, the store was okay overall. I stopped in to grab a few things for the house, and I found what I needed, but some of the aisles were a little messy and dusty. It wasn’t awful or anything, just felt like it could use a bit more upkeep.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Sutherlands?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.